Wicker Smith’s Jaime Baca and Alina Gonzalez obtained a defense verdict in an automobile negligence case

---

Wicker Smith (South Florida)

Wicker Smith Miami Partner Jaime Baca and Associate Alina Gonzalez obtained a defense verdict in an automobile negligence case on behalf of United Automobile Insurance Company in Miami-Dade County in February.

This was an admitted liability case resulting from a minor motor vehicle accident. Plaintiff claimed injuries to her neck and back, but mostly focused on injuries to her right shoulder, for which she underwent an arthroscopic procedure. The medical bills totaled $123,000. Efforts to resolve this case for a reasonable amount were rejected, and the case was set for trial.

Despite the defense presenting evidence that she had been involved in car accidents both before and after the subject incident, Plaintiff continued to insist that this accident was the cause of her injuries and subsequent surgery. In addition to the medical expenses incurred, the plaintiff asked the jury to award her $369,000 in past and future pain and suffering for a total of $492,000 in damages.

After two hours, the jury returned a verdict of no legal cause. Due to the rejection of two separate Proposals for Settlement, the firm’s client will be entitled to seek fees and costs dating from June 2023.